Court ruling · October 29, 2026 · read November 2, 2026
A court struck CMS’s narrower “medically frail” test. Here is what changed.
On October 29, 2026, a federal judge in Massachusetts ruled that CMS went beyond the law when it added a second test to the medical frailty exemption from Medicaid’s work rule. In the states that sued, the exemption now rests on the conditions Congress listed; whether that reaches other states is not settled yet. The federal January 1, 2027 deadline did not move (each state sets its own start within it), and two limits on how states check frailty still stand.
What the court struck
CMS’s rule said a condition counted only if it “significantly impairs the individual’s ability to comply with the community engagement requirement” (42 CFR 435.554(c)(5)(i)). In other words, you had to be too sick to meet the hours, not just very sick. The court held that limit “beyond the powers of CMS” and vacated that language, and its order bars CMS from “implementing, enforcing, retroactively enforcing, or otherwise applying” it to the states that sued.
What is left is the list in the 2025 law (H.R.1, P.L. 119-21). You count as medically frail if you are blind or disabled; have a substance use disorder; have a disabling mental disorder; have a physical, intellectual or developmental disability that significantly impairs one or more daily activities; or have a serious or complex medical condition. The court noted that every other exemption Congress wrote works this way, by category, with no test of whether you could comply.
Sources: the court’s opinion and its order of vacatur and enjoinment, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, No. 1:26-cv-12962-RGS (D. Mass.), October 29, 2026What did not change
- The start date. January 1, 2027, the federal deadline. The court said its ruling has no effect on the date Congress set. Each state sets its own start within it; see your state.
- The 12-month look-back. When a state checks frailty from its own data, only claims and visit records from the 12 months before you apply count. The court upheld this.
- The limit on your own word. A state may accept your own statement of medical frailty only once per enrollment period (42 CFR 435.557(f)(1)(ii)); in 2027 each state may choose to accept it each time it checks, and the once-per-period limit applies from 2028. The court upheld this too.
- Everything else in the rule. The court cut only the one clause and said the rest stands without it: the 80 hours, the other exemptions, and the six-month renewals.
Which states, and what is not settled yet
The states that sued: Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Hawaiʻi, Illinois, Kentucky (through its governor), Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania (through its governor), Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.
For six months from October 29, 2026, the order bars CMS from “penalizing Plaintiff States for any errors or delays in implementing” the rule. It does not move the federal January 1, 2027 deadline.
Not settled: the order’s bar on CMS runs to the states that sued, while its vacatur names no states. Neither the order nor the opinion says whether the struck test is gone in states that did not sue. One trade report says the vacatur applies everywhere (HFMA, October 29). Until that is clear, ask your state’s Medicaid office which definition it uses. CMS declined to comment and could still appeal. A separate suit over the frailty rules, Taylor v. Kennedy, is pending in federal court in Maryland.
A different suit, filed November 5, 2026: Oregon, Minnesota, New Mexico and Washington asked the federal court in Oregon (Oregon v. Oz, No. 6:26-cv-2435) to bar CMS from cutting their existing Medicaid funds if they do not carry out the work rule. It is about state funding, it asks nothing for individual people, and no judge has ruled on it. Until a court does, plan on the rule starting on your state’s date. Source: the states’ complaint. We will update this page when any of these suits changes.
Your state’s own pages may still describe the old test for a while. What each state has published, now marked where the state sued.
What it means if you have a health condition
- If your condition is on the list, you should not have to prove it stops you from working 80 hours, where the ruling applies. Tell your state you have it, in the words of the list.
- Your state checks its own records first, but only the last 12 months. If you have not seen anyone for the condition in the past year, the state’s data may not show it. A visit now puts it in the record.
- From 2028 your own word counts once per enrollment period. After that, the state wants records. A dated record of the condition and what it makes hard, kept on your phone, gives you something to bring. Build it here; nothing is sent.
- If a letter says you do not meet the rule, answer it by its date. How long you have · ask for a fair hearing.
What it means for navigators
- Screen by category, not by work capacity. A script that asks whether the person can work 80 hours is out of date for the frailty question, where the ruling applies. Ask whether they have a condition on the list.
- Check the 12-month window. When was the person last seen for the condition? No visit in a year means the state’s data check can miss it, so help them book one.
- Plan for the one self-attestation. Once it is used, or from 2028, the state wants documentation. Each state decides whose papers it accepts, and many want the provider who treats the person. The ruling does not say a state must accept any particular clinician’s statement.
- That gap, a real condition the state’s 12 months of data does not show, is what a physician-signed attestation is meant to fill. medfrail’s physician review is planned, not open yet. The person’s own doctor or clinic is often the better route, and the dated record helps them. The navigator tools and sign-up.
Sources
Read November 2, 2026. The opinion and the order are the source for every statement about what the court decided; the reports are named where they add something the opinion does not say.
- Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, memorandum and order on cross-motions for summary judgment, D. Mass., October 29, 2026 (Georgetown litigation tracker)
- Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, order of vacatur and enjoinment, D. Mass., October 29, 2026 (Georgetown litigation tracker)
- CMS-2454-IFC, the interim final rule, Federal Register, June 3, 2026
- HFMA, Court vacates CMS medical frailty restriction, October 29, 2026
- Healthcare Dive, Judge strikes down CMS medical frailty policy, October 30, 2026
- California Attorney General, press release, October 29, 2026