medfrail.com

Court ruling · October 29, 2026 · read November 2, 2026

A court struck CMS’s narrower “medically frail” test. Here is what changed.

On October 29, 2026, a federal judge in Massachusetts ruled that CMS went beyond the law when it added a second test to the medical frailty exemption from Medicaid’s work rule. In the states that sued, the exemption now rests on the conditions Congress listed; whether that reaches other states is not settled yet. The federal January 1, 2027 deadline did not move (each state sets its own start within it), and two limits on how states check frailty still stand.

Check if the work rule applies to you Build your dated record

What the court struck

CMS’s rule said a condition counted only if it “significantly impairs the individual’s ability to comply with the community engagement requirement” (42 CFR 435.554(c)(5)(i)). In other words, you had to be too sick to meet the hours, not just very sick. The court held that limit “beyond the powers of CMS” and vacated that language, and its order bars CMS from “implementing, enforcing, retroactively enforcing, or otherwise applying” it to the states that sued.

What is left is the list in the 2025 law (H.R.1, P.L. 119-21). You count as medically frail if you are blind or disabled; have a substance use disorder; have a disabling mental disorder; have a physical, intellectual or developmental disability that significantly impairs one or more daily activities; or have a serious or complex medical condition. The court noted that every other exemption Congress wrote works this way, by category, with no test of whether you could comply.

Sources: the court’s opinion and its order of vacatur and enjoinment, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, No. 1:26-cv-12962-RGS (D. Mass.), October 29, 2026

What did not change

Source: the court’s opinion; the rule itself: CMS-2454-IFC, Federal Register, June 3, 2026

Which states, and what is not settled yet

The states that sued: Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Hawaiʻi, Illinois, Kentucky (through its governor), Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania (through its governor), Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.

For six months from October 29, 2026, the order bars CMS from “penalizing Plaintiff States for any errors or delays in implementing” the rule. It does not move the federal January 1, 2027 deadline.

Not settled: the order’s bar on CMS runs to the states that sued, while its vacatur names no states. Neither the order nor the opinion says whether the struck test is gone in states that did not sue. One trade report says the vacatur applies everywhere (HFMA, October 29). Until that is clear, ask your state’s Medicaid office which definition it uses. CMS declined to comment and could still appeal. A separate suit over the frailty rules, Taylor v. Kennedy, is pending in federal court in Maryland.

A different suit, filed November 5, 2026: Oregon, Minnesota, New Mexico and Washington asked the federal court in Oregon (Oregon v. Oz, No. 6:26-cv-2435) to bar CMS from cutting their existing Medicaid funds if they do not carry out the work rule. It is about state funding, it asks nothing for individual people, and no judge has ruled on it. Until a court does, plan on the rule starting on your state’s date. Source: the states’ complaint. We will update this page when any of these suits changes.

Your state’s own pages may still describe the old test for a while. What each state has published, now marked where the state sued.

What it means if you have a health condition

Sources

Read November 2, 2026. The opinion and the order are the source for every statement about what the court decided; the reports are named where they add something the opinion does not say.

  1. Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, memorandum and order on cross-motions for summary judgment, D. Mass., October 29, 2026 (Georgetown litigation tracker)
  2. Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, order of vacatur and enjoinment, D. Mass., October 29, 2026 (Georgetown litigation tracker)
  3. CMS-2454-IFC, the interim final rule, Federal Register, June 3, 2026
  4. HFMA, Court vacates CMS medical frailty restriction, October 29, 2026
  5. Healthcare Dive, Judge strikes down CMS medical frailty policy, October 30, 2026
  6. California Attorney General, press release, October 29, 2026

Next: does the rule apply to you · your dated record · every state · for navigators